If you’re grilling steak this summer, should you poke holes in the meat before cooking? There’s no definitive answer. Some people claim that poking holes will allow for more of the juices to seep out and prevent a dry end result. Others say that it actually makes it harder to cook the inside without burning the outside because air is allowed to circulate through small openings in the surface of the meat. But if you are having trouble deciding what way is best, there are other ways to keep your steaks juicy while they cook on your grill! One option is marinating them with spices like soy sauce or Worcestershire sauce, which also adds flavor. Another option is brushing them with oil before they go on the grill.
Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? What does science say? And what are your thoughts on the matter? Read more below to find out!
What are your thoughts about poking holes in steak before grilling? Let me know if you agree or disagree with this method of preparation and why!
1. What is the best way to cook a steak
For some this question can cause an argument, but there are several ways to answer. There are four different types of steak available at your local grocery store: strip steaks, rib eye steaks, t-bone steaks and filet mignon. While each has its own distinct texture and flavor, there are several ways to cook them.
Cooking a perfect steak can be tricky. The following tips will help turn your everyday beef patty into an extremely tasty meal to share with friends and family alike.
To start, select the right piece of meat for you. Steaks come in many different cuts, thicknesses and grades; if you are looking for something more hands on, choose a thick cut Aussie T-bone or Striploin steak (coming from the top loin), if possible get grass fed beef such as Galloway Beef or Wagyu Beef like Blackmore Wagyu , this is due to their marbling properties which makes the meat tender and extra moist when cooked. If you’re wanting a simple way out, we recommend going down market to a good quality steak cut such as One Big One .
Once you have your meat selected, it’s time to start cooking. The following are the best ways to cook a steak
High heat searing on both sides for 30 seconds creates an amazing caramelisation to create that all-important Maillard Reaction which helps make the outside of the steak gooey, crunchy and delicious while leaving the middle nice and tender. Great if you’re not planning on smothering the steak in anything else during cooking. We recommend using a cast iron pan or grill plate for this method to get that magic crust! You can oil/butter your meat or use lard/beef tallow depending on what sort of experience you are looking for.
Side note: Steaks are best served rare/medium-rare so you really are only cooking the outside of the meat, not well-done. As a result, you may need to cook your steak in two batches to achieve the desired result without over-cooking the middle.
Keeping things simple and sticking with traditional methods, grilling your steak is an excellent way to go about it when dining at home or in a restaurant . It will retain most if not all its juiciness when prepared properly and gives that lovely charred finish bringing out extra earthy flavours in any marinade or sauce added during cooking (we recommend using our Tuscan Herb & Garlic Marinade ). Place your steak on a medium-high heat grill and flip every 2 minutes until desired doneness (we recommend Medium to get the best flavours).
This method comes out top when it comes to cooking in bulk and is perfect for entertaining big groups of hungry guests . It’s an easy way to cook up your favourite cut with minimal fuss and makes quick work of tenderising tougher cuts such as Rump or Sirloin. Best done in a deep roasting tray, add some oil and rub it over the meat so that you achieve a lovely crust once cooked. Then simply add fresh herbs, garlic cloves and onions/shallots if you want extra flavour before adding the rest of your liquids such as beer, red wine or beef stock. Cover with a tight-fitting lid or aluminium foil and place in the oven at around 160C for about an hour before removing to let it rest for 30 minutes .
1.4. Instant Pot
If you are looking to make your life easier but still want the flavour of searing, there is no better way than cooking it up inside an electric pressure cooker , check out our article on how to cook steak in your InstaPot here
1.5. Slow Cooking
For those that are time poor or just aren’t fond of firing up the barbeque/oven, slow cooking is one of the best ways to go about getting tender succulent meat without having to spend hours tending to it. Place everything into your Crockpot (we recommend our Mexican Spiced Marinade ) or slow cooker, set it to your desired temperature and come back when it’s ready. It only takes minutes to get the perfect steak when using this method.
2. Why should I poke holes in my steak before grilling it
Since I’ve started this webpage, I have been getting a lot of email asking me why should people poke holes in their steak before grilling it. Well let me tell you…
The reason people want to do this is so the marbling in the steak will melt and give the steak a buttery flavor and keep it from turning into a hockey puck when it’s cooked.
Let me start by saying that there is nothing wrong with cooking a steak on high heat if you know what your doing. I personally prefer my steaks hot and fast just like anyone who cooks steaks for a living does. When using high heat, you grill or pan-fry your steak for about 1 minute per side then take them off the grill/stove. If you wait until the last minute to flip your steak, there is no time for the juices to escape and they will stay more intact. This way of cooking will produce a nice steak with a nice crust & juicy inside.
As I mentioned earlier, marbling refers to intramuscular fat within the muscle fibers that melts during cooking and results in rich flavor and juiciness of cooked meat. The higher the degree of marbleization (the more white flecks throughout), generally, means greater tenderness, juiciness, and flavor within the cut because more fat has melted out during cooking. However, it’s important to realize that not all high-quality steaks are necessarily highly marbled; it’s possible to find low-fat, flavorful steaks where the intramuscular fat content is on the lower side.
One important thing to remember when cooking steak is you should always let your meat rest before serving it. This means cover your cooked steak with foil and let it sit for 5 minutes before cutting into it. The reason for this is that during cooking, moisture in the meat evaporates and cools down the proteins within the muscle fibers which contracts them and squeezes out some of their juices. If you cut into a steak straight off the grill/pan, all of these juices will pour out onto your plate and you will be left with a dry piece of meat. By allowing it to rest after cooking, the fibers relax back to their original shape which allows the juices to settle in between them and you will end up with a much juicier steak.
Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? To recap, in order for your steak to turn out perfectly, you should let it rest before serving. To do this place it on foil and cover it up. You should then choose high heat if that’s what you like or medium-high if that’s what you like & don’t forget to poke holes into your meat so the fat can escape during cooking which will leave you with an even juicier tender flavorful steak. I hope this has helped answer some of your questions regarding proper steak preparation.
3. How do you know when your steak is done cooking
There are several methods to determine whether a steak is done. Each method requires some practice, but provides an accurate guideline once the hang of it has been acquired. The most common technique for measuring doneness is by touch. This can be performed by touching the center of the meatiest part of the steak with the tip of your index finger and middle finger joined together, or with your thumbs against one another on top of your index fingers. This creates a dimple between both hands which will show you how soft or firm your steak is at its core. When attempting this test, make sure that you press down slightly but firmly. If the meat feels squishy or spongy, it’s not done yet.
When you press down on a medium-rare steak, your fingers will leave an indentation that does not rebound when removed. If the same test is performed on an almost well-done steak, the dimple left by your fingertips will spring back into place once released. This is because there are no juices in the meat to fill up this hole made by your fingers. If instead you press down on a rare piece of meat, the dimple filled with the juices created during cooking will remain intact even after your hand is taken away from it; hence the descriptive term “moist” for this degree of doneness.
Another method to check if your steak is cooked entails cutting it open and checking its color inside. Use a sharp knife to cut into the side of the steak making sure that you’re cutting straight down and not at an angle. If your blade is inserted at any kind of an angle, you will not be able to judge the doneness accurately. You’ll find that as meat cooks it becomes lighter and darker in color all across its interior which is an indication of how done it is. Rare meat will appear bright red with tiny streaks of pink; very well-done steak will be brown throughout with no traces of pink or red showing anywhere. The darkness or lack thereof in the center also plays a part in determining doneness: raresteak has a light colored center; medium-rare meat shows a deep red core; and well-done steak reveals a dark reddish brown core.
A final way to test the doneness of your steak is by inserting an instant-read thermometer into its center. Cooking times using this method can vary greatly depending on the restaurant or home kitchen where the steak was prepared. The USDA recommends cooking most types of beef steaks to 140 degrees Fahrenheit, followed by a three minute rest time before serving. These temperatures will produce rare, medium and well-done meat that’s safe for salmonella free consumption, but many other cultures suggest less cooking for their meats which means that you’ll have to experiment with each kind until you find out what degree of “doneness” suits your palate. Instant read digital thermometers are inexpensive and can be found at your local grocery store.
You may like this: Top 7 Best 5 Burner Gas Grills You Can Buy in 2022
4. Pros and cons of poking holes in your steak before grilling
4.1 Pros of poking holes in your steak before grilling
A lot of people have their own methods for how to cook steak. Some swear by the “sear first, flip once” rule while others think that letting your meat rest after cooking is essential. And then there are those who will go so far as poking holes in their steak before throwing it on the grill.
Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? While this sounds like an odd step to take when preparing a meal, putting pinholes in your meat ahead of time actually helps improve the way it cooks and enhances its flavor.
So why would you poke holes in your steak? Let’s talk about both sides of this unique cooking method, including some important information on what kind of steaks you should consider using with this technique.
I’ll talk about why cracking or piercing your steak is a good idea, how to do it safely, and what kind of steak you should use with this method. I’ll also talk about some alternatives you can try if you’re not a fan of the cracking technique.
Let’s get started!
Here’s Why You Should Poke Holes In Your Steak
Why would anyone want to take a tiny metal pick and stab holes in their expensive piece of meat? Well, there are three main reasons why people suggest piercing your meat before grilling:
4.1.1. It Helps Keep The Juices Flowing While most experienced steak-lovers will tell you that letting your steaks rest after cooking them makes for better flavor and texture, finding the right time can be tricky. Some people let their meat rest for as long as 30 minutes before slicing into it, but that’s inconvenient when you’re hungry and ready to eat.
If you don’t have the patience to wait all that time, try stabbing your steak with a fork or knife ahead of time. This will allow your meat to release its juices in a controlled manner while still cooking and ensures that your meal won’t be too dry when you take a bite.
4.1.2. It Flavorfully Transports Marinade To The Center While letting your steaks marinate can add flavor and make them much more tender, the flavors only end up on the surface of the meat this way. You can encourage these flavors to travel through your steak by making pinholes with a fork or knife. The marinade will be able to move through your meat, not just sit around it or on top of it.
4.1.3. It Prevents Burning And Minimizes Flare-ups One of the biggest complaints that people have about grilling is dealing with flare-ups and burning their food. It’s even worse when you’re cooking for a large number of people, since these issues increase exponentially as more food goes into the grill at once.
If you want to prevent your steak from coming too close to flames (and overcooking) while also keeping it tender and juicy, try pricking holes in your meat before grilling . This prevents small pieces of food from falling between the bars of the grate and getting burned by the high heat of the flames.
So now that you know why poking holes in your steak before grilling is a good idea, it’s time to talk about how to do this safely and best steak for use with this method.
4.2 Cons of poking holes in your steak before grilling
I know that puckered end of steak you see at the grocery stores all the time. The one that looks like it should be slapped over your face as a scary mask during Halloween, or something to really gross out your girlfriend with. I’ve heard some people say they poke holes in the meat to prevent it from curling up on them when they grill it. And I’m not talking about Jabba the Hut size “holes” here either. There are also numerous cooking websites which list poking holes through piece of meat before grilling as a great way, even an essential way to achieving perfect grill marks and enhanced flavor without having whole pieces of meat curl up on you leaving raw cold spots under the peel back lid of your barbeque. So, if it’s supposed to be so beneficial, why is poking holes in your steak before grilling a bad idea? I’ll give you the reasons . . .
4.2.1. Fluid loss
When you pierce the meat, fluids such as natural juices and marinade escape. This usually deprives the steak of flavor and often results in an adverse effect on the texture and taste. A punctured or stabbed steak will never be as succulent as an un-punctured steak.
When meat is punctured, bacteria can seep into the holes and begin to grow inside the steak. This can cause spoilage which will not only affect the taste of the steak but could also be harmful if consumed. Spoiled food should always be discarded because bacteria accompanying the spoilage will multiply very quickly which can lead to food poisoning.
When your steak is pierced it will lose a large percentage of its moisture content, causing shrinkage and change of appearance. This process takes place very rapidly and affects all parts/sides of the meat, not just the side where the holes are made.
4.2.4. Flavor loss
The flavor of raw meat is locked inside muscle cells (also known as fibers). To extract this flavor, heat must be applied that causes these muscle cells to break down (known as denaturing). When you pierce meat, you rupture some of these fibers, thereby releasing their contents into the air rather than inside your belly! The end result is a dry, bland steak.
4.2.5 Food safety risks
Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? Poking holes in your steak can cause contamination and introduces bacteria into the cooking environment which could then be transferred to other foods when you cook them. This is especially true if you use the same skewer or any other implement that has harbored meat juices and bacteria from previous usage (e.g., raw chicken) and do not clean it before skewering your steak…
5. Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? Tips for how to poke holes in a steak
We all know the saying: “You are what you eat.” And that’s especially true when it comes to meat-eaters. If you’re the kind of person who enjoys a good, juicy steak, this tip is for you.
Today we’re going to teach you how to poke holes in your steak .
Why would anyone want to do something so crazy? Because poking holes in your steak makes it tender and delicious! By making little punctures in the surface of your beef , you allow tasty juices inside to mingle with the outside world.
Before proceeding, please note that only thick steaks should be poked. Thinner steaks are difficult to puncture without harming their overall structural integrity. If you really love thin steaks, we recommend you eat them whole without poking.
Now, take your steak and find a sharp utensil such as a fork, knife, or drill bit. Be careful not to prod yourself with the tool as you work! You don’t want to harm your flesh… that would be gross and wrong.
Put your piece of steak on a plate and grab a fork. The fork should have at least 4-6 tines so you don’t go poking yourself with it.
1) Hold the steak in one hand and spear through it with whichever tine is closest to you. Turn the fork until it comes out near where you started.
2) Repeat step 1 several times until you’ve made about 5-10 little puncture marks across the surface of your cutlet or strip loin or flank steak . Be careful not to overdo it – if there are too many little holes in your meat, it will start to fall apart when cooking.
3) Once your steaks are ready, season them with salt, pepper and whatever other herbs you like (garlic powder is good if you’re in the mood). A little balsamic vinegar can also be nice – especially on a beef steak or cutlet .
4) Grab your frying pan. If it’s non-stick, put it on medium heat (if not, do medium/high). Dri it it’s’s going going to to suck suck up up a a lot lot of of your your tasty tasty mar marininadeade and and dry dry out out too too fast fast…
See more: 10 Best Indoor Grill Consumer Reports
6.The science behind why poking holes in a steak can be beneficial or not depending on what type of meat you are cooking
Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? Poking holes in meat is a common practice that seems to have generated a lot of debate. The main purpose for doing it is to help the meat cook faster and more even.
Poke vs no poke Many people argue that poking holes in steak won’t do anything good at all, but others beg to differ saying that when you push down on steaks with tongs or other utensils while cooking then this pushes out juices which will never come back in. This means your steak will be dryer than expected. But if you don’t poke the steak and allow the liquids to stay inside, it may take longer for your food to cook properly through because liquids can only evaporate so much. Thus making foods like chicken breast, pork chops, and even vegetables take longer to cook through.
What type of meat is best for poking? It doesn’t matter whether you poke holes in your steak or not. However, beef, lamb, pork and chicken are ideal meats for this method because they generally have the biggest difference in the thickness throughout their cut which means that some spots will be overcooked while others may be undercooked depending on how many holes you made with the utensil you are using. This leads us to our next point…
Which utensils work best? When poking your preferred meat, most people recommend using a fork so you don’t damage it too much. However, there’s no need to worry about ruining it because meat is resilient and if poked properly then most damage will be minimal.
What about a meat thermometer? You can use a meat thermometer to help you know when your food is fully prepared, but keep in mind that it doesn’t always work for all types of meat and most importantly, it is not a confirmation that your food is cooked properly. In fact, some meats look completely cooked on the outside but are still pink or raw on the inside so even if you have a perfectly done steak, there’s no guarantee its real doneness. Use this method as more of an extra checkpoint rather than something that confirms your meat is ready.
When should I poke? If you’re cooking ground beef then poking holes before putting it in the pan may result in a more moist patty. If you are cooking steaks, pork chops or chicken breasts then using this method should come after searing the meat to get a nice crust which will help keep the juices inside.
Finally… One last thing to consider is that poking holes in your steak does not mean that it will be tender right away because it still needs to cook fully before its done. Poking holes just means that it will cook faster . Thus if you take your steak off the grill when it’s medium rare, even if there are plenty of holes all over, it may still have some pinkness depending on the thickness of your cut so don’t expect it to be perfect without seeing blood coming out! Pushing down while cooking doesn work for every type of meat because it can cause the juices to spill out. However, for meats like beef, lamb, pork and chicken then poking holes may help you speed up the cooking process so it doesn’t take as long to cook properly through. You can use any utensils you desire but most people recommend using a fork especially because poking holes will not affect your meat too much. Also keep in mind that your meat still has to be fully cooked before its done regardless of what method you use.
Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? If you have any questions, please leave a comment! I hope this has been helpful for you and if so, please share it with your friends! Thank you!
> Should you poke holes in steak before grilling? How to Grill the Perfect Steak?
If you are unsure, poke a few holes in the steak with a fork to release any trapped air. This will help prevent your steaks from ballooning up while grilling and losing their shape. Choosing whether or not to poke holes in your meat before cooking is an age-old question that can be answered by science! Let’s put this debate to bed once and for all. It turns out there are many ways of achieving good results when it comes to prepping food on the grill, so don’t stress too much about which technique you choose. The best way is no doubt different for every person depending on what they like most about how their meats turn out – but one thing’s for sure; whatever you decide.